Model 3 vs Model S: What Sets Them Apart?

Selecting a car can be a complex process, with various aspects to consider, such as performance, cost, size, and the technology incorporated into the vehicle. When it comes to electric cars, Tesla, a world-renowned automaker, tops the list with its variety of models. Two of its most acclaimed offerings are the Tesla Model S and the Tesla Model 3.

Each has its strengths and weaknesses, depending on your specific requirements and budget. This article provides an in-depth comparison between the Tesla Model 3 and the Tesla Model S, discussing aspects such as power, performance, pricing, and more.

Tesla Model 3 vs Model S

1.     Performance & Power

Tesla Model 3

The Tesla Model 3 stands out as an efficient electric sedan. The Performance variant of the Model 3 can accelerate from 0 to 60 mph in just 3.1 seconds. It offers a top speed of 162 mph, powered by its dual-motor, all-wheel-drive system. Its range varies depending on the model, with the Standard Range Plus offering 263 miles, and the Long Range and Performance models offering 353 miles on a full charge.

Tesla Model S

The Model S, on the other hand, has been the flagship vehicle of Tesla and is renowned for its blistering speed and performance. The Model S Plaid reaches 0-60 mph in less than 2 seconds, claimed to be the fastest by any production car ever. The Long Range variant of the Model S offers a top speed of 155 mph and a whopping 412 miles of range.

2.     Price

Tesla Model 3

When it comes to cost-effectiveness, the Tesla Model 3 stands as a winner. The Standard Range Plus starts at around $39,990, while the Performance model is priced from $56,990.

Tesla Model S

The Tesla Model S, being the premium model, has a higher price tag. The Long Range variant starts at about $84,990, and the high-performance Plaid variant is priced from $129,990.

3.     Comfort

Tesla Model 3

The Tesla Model 3 has a modern, minimalist interior design with seating for five. The seats are comfortable, with ample legroom and headroom for most passengers. The noise insulation is impressive, and the ride quality is generally good, although some have reported it to be somewhat firm.

Tesla Model S

As Tesla’s luxury sedan, the Model S offers a higher level of comfort. It also seats five, but there’s more legroom and headroom overall. The ride quality is smoother and more refined compared to the Model 3. The Model S also offers optional features for enhancing comfort, such as heated and ventilated seats, and a heated steering wheel.

4.     Technology

Tesla Model 3

The Model 3 offers a minimalist approach to interior design, with almost all controls handled through a centrally-mounted 15-inch touchscreen. This controls everything from the climate control system to the vehicle’s speedometer. Tesla’s Autopilot driver-assistance system is standard, and the car receives regular over-the-air updates for improving its features and functionality over time.

Tesla Model S

The Model S features a 17-inch vertical touchscreen and a separate driver’s display in the traditional instrument panel location. It also includes a premium audio system and has access to the same over-the-air updates as the Model 3. The latest Model S also comes with Tesla’s newest version of the Autopilot system, which includes more advanced autonomous driving features.

5.     Safety

Tesla Model 3

The Model 3 has received high marks for safety. It’s been awarded a 5-star safety rating from the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) and has performed well in tests from other organizations. Tesla’s Autopilot system provides a suite of safety features, including collision warning and automatic emergency braking.

Tesla Model S

The Model S has also been rated highly for safety by various organizations. It also includes the full suite of Autopilot safety features, and has the advantage of having a lower center of gravity than most vehicles, which helps with stability and handling and reduces the risk of rollover.

In sum, both the Model 3 and Model S are strong contenders when it comes to comfort, technology, and safety. The choice between the two will largely depend on your individual needs, preferences, and budget.

6.     Cargo Space

Tesla Model 3

The Model 3 provides a total of 15 cubic feet of cargo space, divided between the rear trunk and a smaller ‘frunk’ (front trunk). This should be sufficient for most daily needs, including grocery shopping or short trips.

Tesla Model S

The Model S boasts significantly more cargo space than the Model 3 – up to 28 cubic feet, which expands to 58 cubic feet when you fold down the rear seats. It also includes a front trunk. This extra space makes the Model S more suited for long trips or for families who need more storage capacity.

7.     Maintenance and Warranty

Tesla Model 3

The Model 3, like all Teslas, has the advantage of requiring less regular maintenance than a gasoline-powered car. Tesla offers a 4-year/50,000-mile basic warranty and an 8-year/100,000-mile battery and powertrain warranty for the Model 3.

Tesla Model S

The Model S has the same basic warranty as the Model 3, but its battery and powertrain warranty extends to 8 years, regardless of miles driven, which could be an advantage for high-mileage drivers.

8.     Environmental Impact

Tesla Model 3

The Model 3 is highly efficient, even among electric cars. It consumes approximately 25 kWh per 100 miles, resulting in very low running costs and carbon footprint.

Tesla Model S

The Model S is also efficient, but being a larger car, its energy consumption is slightly higher than the Model 3 – around 28-35 kWh per 100 miles, depending on the version. It’s still far more efficient than most gas-powered vehicles and offers a lower carbon footprint.

To conclude, while the Model 3 shines in efficiency and cost-effectiveness, the Model S outperforms in luxury, cargo space, and high-mileage warranty coverage. Both cars hold strong environmental credentials. The decision between the two will ultimately boil down to personal preferences, needs, and budget.

Does A Model S Drive Better Than A Model 3?

The driving experience between the Tesla Model S and Model 3 is subjective and depends on personal preferences. However, the Model S, being a luxury sedan, generally offers a smoother, more refined driving experience compared to the Model 3.

The Model S is equipped with an adaptive air suspension system that provides a plush ride, soaking up bumps and rough surfaces more effectively than the Model 3’s traditional coil-over suspension. Moreover, the Model S’s dual-motor all-wheel drive gives it better traction and stability, leading to superior handling and performance.

Which Model Is The Best In Tesla?

As of my knowledge cutoff in September 2021, the “best” model would be subjective and depends on what you prioritize in a vehicle. If you prioritize performance and luxury, then the Model S, particularly the Plaid variant, would likely be considered the best due to its top-tier speed, acceleration, and premium features.

If affordability and efficiency are more important, then the Model 3 would stand out as the best choice due to its lower price point and excellent range and performance for its cost. The Model X and Model Y also have their merits, particularly for those needing more cargo space or preferring an SUV body style.

Why Does The Model S Cost So Much?

The Tesla Model S carries a higher price tag primarily because it is positioned as a premium luxury vehicle. The costs associated with manufacturing the Model S are greater due to various factors, including:

Materials and Construction

The Model S uses higher-end materials both in the interior (like leather and wood trim) and exterior (like aluminium body), which cost more to source and assemble.

Performance

The Model S is designed for high performance, with advanced engineering and superior components such as the high-performance drive units, suspension system, and premium brakes.

Technology

The Model S includes advanced technology features such as a larger and more complex infotainment system, advanced Autopilot capabilities, and premium sound system.

Battery and range

The battery pack in the Model S is larger and more costly to produce than the one in the Model 3. This is part of what allows the Model S to offer a greater driving range.

Overall, the Model S’s higher cost is reflective of its position as a luxury, high-performance vehicle with advanced technology and superior driving range.

How Does The Acceleration Of The Tesla Model S Compare To The Model 3?

Acceleration is one area where the Tesla Model S significantly outperforms the Model 3. The Model S Plaid, the high-performance variant, is capable of accelerating from 0 to 60 mph in under 2 seconds. This makes it one of the fastest production cars in the world.

On the other hand, the quickest Model 3 variant, the Performance model, accomplishes the same sprint in 3.1 seconds. While the Model 3’s acceleration is impressive in its own right, the Model S offers a level of performance that few vehicles can match.

Why Is The Tesla Model S Generally Considered More Luxurious Than The Model 3?

The Tesla Model S is considered more luxurious due to its premium design, materials, and additional features. The Model S includes high-end materials such as leather and wood trim in the interior, giving it a more opulent feel. It also offers more optional features like ventilated seats and a heated steering wheel.

Additionally, its air suspension system provides a smoother, more comfortable ride. The Model S also features a larger 17-inch infotainment display compared to the Model 3’s 15-inch display, further enhancing its luxury appeal.

What Makes The Tesla Model 3 A More Cost-Effective Option Compared To The Model S?

The Tesla Model 3 is a more cost-effective option primarily due to its lower purchase price. The starting price of a Model 3 is significantly lower than that of a Model S. This makes it more accessible for a broader range of consumers.

Furthermore, the Model 3 still offers many of the core features that Tesla is known for, such as impressive electric range, robust performance, advanced safety features, and access to the Supercharger network. Therefore, despite its lower price, the Model 3 still provides a substantial amount of value.

How Does The Cargo Space In The Tesla Model S And Model 3 Compare?

The Model S offers significantly more cargo space compared to the Model 3. It provides up to 28 cubic feet of space, which can be expanded to 58 cubic feet when the rear seats are folded down.

The Model 3, in comparison, offers 15 cubic feet of cargo space divided between the trunk and a smaller front trunk, also known as the ‘frunk’. The extra space in the Model S makes it more suitable for those who often carry a lot of luggage, equipment, or frequently go on longer trips.

How Do The Warranties For The Tesla Model S And Model 3 Differ?

Both the Model S and Model 3 come with a 4-year/50,000-mile basic vehicle warranty. However, there is a difference when it comes to their battery and powertrain warranties. For the Model 3, Tesla provides an 8-year/100,000-mile warranty, while for the Model S, it’s an 8-year warranty with unlimited miles.

This unlimited-mileage warranty on the Model S could provide better coverage and peace of mind for drivers who accumulate high mileage in a short period of time.

Are There Significant Differences In Energy Consumption Between The Tesla Model S And Model 3?

Yes, there is a noticeable difference in energy consumption between the two models. The Model 3 is highly efficient and consumes approximately 25 kWh per 100 miles. This efficiency results in lower running costs and a smaller carbon footprint.

The Model S, while still efficient compared to gasoline vehicles, consumes more energy due to its larger size and higher performance capabilities. The energy consumption for the Model S ranges from around 28-35 kWh per 100 miles, depending on the specific variant.

Given The Differences Between The Model 3 And Model S, How Should One Choose Between Them?

Choosing between the Tesla Model 3 and Model S ultimately depends on individual preferences, requirements, and budget. If you prioritize cost-effectiveness, efficiency, and still want a high-performing electric vehicle, the Model 3 might be the right choice. It offers substantial value and a range of features at a significantly lower price point than the Model S.

On the other hand, if you prioritize maximum performance, greater range, higher luxury, more cargo space, and advanced technology, the Model S could be a better choice. It offers exceptional acceleration and speed, a plush and premium interior, more cargo capacity, a superior infotainment system, and an unlimited-mileage warranty on the battery and powertrain. However, these features come at a significantly higher cost compared to the Model 3.

Conclusion

The final decision should balance your specific needs and wants against your budget. Consider factors like how you plan to use the car, the importance of additional luxury features and space to you, your driving habits, and how much you’re willing to spend on a vehicle. It’s also a good idea to test drive both vehicles if possible to get a better sense of which one suits you best.